Economic and Social Development: Accord for a Firm and Lasting Peace

Agreement on Social and Economic Aspects and the Agrarian Situation (Mexico City, 6 May 1996)

I. Democratization and Participatory Development: A. Participation and consensus-building

1. In order to pursue a true, functional and participatory democracy, the process of social and economic development should be democratic and participatory and include: (a) consensus-building and dialogue among agents of socio-economic development; (b) consensus-building between these agents and State bodies in the formulation and implementation of development strategies; and (c) effective citizen participation in identifying, prioritizing and meeting their needs.

2. Expanded social participation is a bulwark against corruption, privilege, distortions of development and the abuse of economic and political power to the detriment of society. Therefore, it is an instrument for the eradication of economic, social and political polarization in society.

3. In addition to representing a factor in democratization, citizen participation in economic and social development is essential in order to promote productivity and economic growth, achieve a more equitable distribution of wealth and train human resources. It ensures transparency in public policies and their orientation towards the common good rather than special interests, the effective protection of the interests of the most vulnerable groups, efficiency in providing services and, consequently, the integral development of the individual.

4. In this spirit, and in line with the agreements already concluded on the resettlement of the population groups uprooted by the armed conflict and on identity and rights of indigenous peoples, the Parties agree on the importance of establishing or strengthening mechanisms allowing the citizens and different social groups to exercise their rights effectively and participate fully in decision-making on the various matters affecting or involving them, with full awareness of both their individual and collective obligations to society, which they will fulfill responsibly.

5. Strengthening social participation means that greater opportunities in social and economic decision-making should be offered to organized groups. This assumes that all kinds of grass-roots organizations representing different interests will be recognized and encouraged. It requires, in particular, the guarantee of full and effective rights for rural and urban workers and small farmers to participate, as organized entities, in the process of building consensus with the business sector or at the national level. For this purpose, flexible laws and administrative regulations must be passed to grant legal personality or other forms of legal recognition to those organizations requesting it.

6. This also assumes a major effort to promote a culture of consensus and capacity-building in business, labor and other types of organizations in order to increase their ability to plan and negotiate and effectively to assume the rights and duties inherent in democratic participation.

Consensus-building

7. Building consensus at the national, departmental and communal levels and among rural and urban units of production is essential in order to stimulate and stabilize economic and social growth. State structures must be adapted to fulfill this role of building consensus and reconciling interests, in order to be able to work effectively and efficiently to modernize the production sector, enhance competitiveness, promote economic growth and provide basic social services efficiently and universally.

Participation at the local level

8. Bearing in mind that the people who live in a department or municipality, whether business owners, workers, members of cooperatives or community representatives, are the ones who can best define the measures that benefit or affect them, a package of instruments must be adopted for institutionalizing the decentralization of social and economic decision-making, involving a real transfer of government funds and of the authority to discuss and decide locally on the allocation of resources, how projects will be executed and the priorities and characteristics of government programs or activities. In this way, government bodies will be able to base their actions on proposals arising from the reconciliation of interests among the various segments of society.

9. Through this Agreement, the Government commits itself to take a series of steps designed to increase the people’s participation in the various aspects of public life, including social and rural development policies. This series of reforms must enable structures that generate social conflict to be replaced by new relationships that ensure the consolidation of peace, as an expression of harmonious life together, and the strengthening of democracy, as a dynamic and perfectible process from which advances can be achieved through the participation of various segments of society in shaping the country’s political, social and economic choices.

10. In order to reinforce the people’s ability to participate and, at the same time, the State’s management capacity, the Government agrees to:

Communities

(a) Promote a reform of the Municipal Code so that deputy mayors are appointed by the municipal mayor, taking into account the recommendations of local residents in an open town council meeting;

Municipalities

(b) Foster social participation in the context of municipal autonomy, pursuing the process of decentralization to give more authority to municipal governments, and consequently, strengthening their technical, administrative and financial resources;

(c) Establish and implement as soon as possible, in cooperation with the National Association of Municipalities, a municipal training program that will serve as a framework for national efforts and international cooperation in this field. The program will stress the training of municipal staff who will specialize in executing the new duties that will be the responsibility of the municipality as a result of decentralization, with an emphasis on land use planning, a land register, urban planning, financial management, project management and training of local organizations so that they can participate effectively in meeting their own needs;

Departments

(d) Promote in the Congress a reform of the Act concerning the governance of the departments of the Republic, to the effect that the governor of the department would be appointed by the President of the Republic, taking into consideration the candidates nominated by the non-governmental representatives of the departmental development councils;

Regions

(e) Regionalize health care, education and cultural services for indigenous people and ensure the full participation of indigenous organizations in the design and implementation of this process;

System of urban and rural development councils

(f) Take the following steps, bearing in mind the fundamental role of urban and rural development councils in ensuring, promoting and guaranteeing the people’s participation in the identification of local priorities, the definition of public projects and programs and the integration of national policy into urban and rural development:

(i) Re-establish local development councils;

(ii) Promote a reform of the Urban and Rural Development Councils Act to broaden the range of sectors participating in departmental and regional development councils;

(iii) Provide adequate funding for the council system.

II. Social Development

14. The State is responsible for promoting, guiding and regulating the country’s socio-economic development so as to ensure economic efficiency, increased social services and social justice in an integrated manner and through the efforts of society as a whole. In the quest for growth, economic policy should be aimed at preventing processes of socio-economic exclusion, such as unemployment and impoverishment, and maximizing the benefits of economic growth for all Guatemalans. In seeking to ensure the well-being of all Guatemalans, social policy should foster economic development through its impact on production and efficiency.

15. Guatemala requires speedy economic growth in order to create jobs and enhance social development. The country’s social development, in turn, is essential for its economic growth and for better integration into the world economy. In this regard, better living standards, health, education and training are the pillars of sustainable development in Guatemala.
State responsibilities

16. The State has inescapable obligations in the task of correcting social inequities and deficiencies, both by steering the course of development and by making public investments and providing universal social services. Likewise, the State has the specific obligations, imposed by constitutional mandate, of ensuring the effective enjoyment, without discrimination of any kind, of the right to work, health, education and housing, as well as other social rights. The historical social imbalances experienced in Guatemala must be corrected, and peace must be consolidated, through decisive policies which are implemented by both the State and society as a whole.

Productive investments

17. The country's socio-economic development cannot depend exclusively on public finances or on international cooperation. Rather, it requires an increase in productive investments that create adequately paid jobs. The Parties urge national and foreign entrepreneurs to invest in the country, considering that the signing and implementation of an agreement on a firm and lasting peace are essential components of the stability and transparency required for investment and economic expansion.

Gross domestic product
18. For its part, the Government undertakes to adopt economic policies designed to achieve steady growth in the gross domestic product of not less than 6 per cent per annum, which would enable it to implement a progressive social policy. At the same time, it undertakes to implement a social policy aimed at ensuring the well-being of all Guatemalans, with emphasis on health, nutrition, education and training, housing, environmental sanitation and access to productive employment and to decent pay.

The State's leadership role

19. To meet this objective and to enable the State to play its leadership role in social policy, the Government undertakes to:

(a) Apply and develop the regulatory framework to guarantee the exercise of social rights and provide social services through public entities and, where necessary, through semi-public or private entities, and supervise the adequate provision of such services;

(b) Promote and ensure the participation, in accordance with the regulatory framework, of all social and economic sectors that can cooperate in social development, particularly in providing full access to basic services;

(c) Ensure that the public sector provides services efficiently, considering that the State has a duty to give the population access to quality services.

20. In response to the population's urgent demands, the Government undertakes to:

(a) Increase social investment significantly, especially in the areas of health, education and employment;

(b) Restructure the budget so as to increase social expenditure;

(c) Give priority to the neediest sectors of society and the most disadvantaged areas of the country, without short-changing other sectors of society;

(d) Improve the administration of government resources and investments by decentralizing them and making them less concentrated and bureaucratic, reforming budget performance mechanisms by giving them autonomy in decisionmaking and financial management to guarantee their efficiency and transparency, and strengthening supervisory and auditing mechanisms.

B. Health

23. The Parties agree on the need to promote a reform of the national health sector. This reform should be aimed at ensuring effective exercise of the fundamental right to health, without any discrimination whatsoever, and the effective performance by the State, which would be provided with the necessary resources, of its obligation with regard to health and social welfare. Some of the main points of this reform are as follows:

Concept

(a) It would be based on an integrated concept of health (including prevention, promotion, recovery and rehabilitation) and on humanitarian and community-based practice emphasizing the spirit of service, and it would be applied at all levels of the country’s public health sector;

National coordinated health system

(b) One of the responsibilities of the Ministry of Health is to formulate policies to provide the entire Guatemalan population with integrated health services. Under the coordination of the Ministry of Health, the health system would combine the work of public agencies (including the Guatemalan Social Security Institute) and private and non-governmental organizations involved in this sector to implement actions designed to enable the whole Guatemalan population to have access to integrated health services;

Low-income population

(c) The system would create the conditions for ensuring that the low income population has effective access to quality health services. The Government undertakes to increase the resources it allocates to health. By the year 2000, the Government proposes to step up public spending on health as a proportion of gross domestic product by at least 50 per cent over its 1995 level. This target will be revised upwards in the light of future developments in State finances;

Priority care

(d) The system would give priority to efforts to fight malnutrition and to promote environmental sanitation, preventive health care and primary health care, especially maternal and child care. The Government undertakes to allocate at least 50 per cent of public health expenditure to preventive care and undertakes to cut the 1995 infant and maternal mortality rate in half by the year 2000. In addition, the Government undertakes to maintain the certification of eradication of poliomyelitis, and to eradicate measles by the year 2000;

Medicine, equipment and inputs

(e) The Ministry of Public Health and Social Welfare will revise current rules and practices with regard to the manufacture and marketing of drugs, equipment and inputs and will promote measures to ensure that these are in sufficient supply and that they are affordable and of high quality. In the case of popular basic or generic drugs, ways of purchasing them will be studied and applied in order to ensure transparency in their marketing, quality and pricing to ensure that services are provided efficiently;

Indigenous and traditional medicine

(f) The system would enhance the importance of indigenous and traditional medicine, promoting its study and renewing its concepts, methods and practices;

Social participation

(g) The system would encourage active participation of municipalities, communities and social organizations (including groups of women, indigenous people, trade unions and civic and humanitarian associations) in the planning, execution and monitoring of the administration of health services and programs, through local health systems and urban and rural development councils;

Administrative decentralization and enhancement of local autonomy

(h) The decentralized organization of the various levels of health care should ensure that health programs and services are offered at the community, regional and national levels, which are the basis of the national coordinated health system.

C. Social security

24. Social security is a mechanism for expressing human solidarity and promoting the common good, laying the foundations for stability, economic development, national unity and peace. Under the Political Constitution of the Republic, the Guatemalan Social Security Institute, an autonomous body, administers the social security system. The Parties consider that appropriate measures should be taken to expand its coverage and increase its benefits and the quality and efficiency of its services. To that end, the following should be taken into account:

(a) The administration of the Guatemalan Social Security Institute should be completely autonomous, in accordance with the constitutional principle of coordination with health agencies under the national coordinated health system;

(b) Under the International Labour Organization convention ratified by Guatemala, social security should include programs for medical care and benefits in the areas of sickness, maternity, disability, old age, survival, job-related accidents and illnesses, employment and family welfare;

(c) The application of the principles of efficiency, universality, unity and compulsoriness to the operation of the Guatemalan Social Security Institute should be reinforced and guaranteed;

(d) The financial soundness of the Institute should be strengthened through a system of tripartite control of contributions;

(e) New ways of managing the Institute with the participation of its constituent sectors should be promoted;

(f) The Institute should be effectively incorporated into the coordinated health system;

(g) Conditions should be created that will facilitate the universal coverage of all workers by the social security system.

D. Housing

25. It has been recognized that there is a need to institute a policy, in accordance with the constitutional mandate, to give priority to the building of low-cost housing, through appropriate financial arrangements, in order to enable as many Guatemalan families as possible to own their own homes. To this end, the Government undertakes to:

Planning

(a) Closely monitor land management policies, especially urban planning and environmental protection policies, to enable the poor to have access to housing and related services in hygienic and environmentally sustainable conditions;

Standards

(b) Update health and safety regulations applicable to the construction industry and monitor compliance with them; coordinate with municipalities to ensure that construction and supervision standards are homogeneous, clear and simple, in an effort to provide high-quality, safe housing;

Housing stock

(c) Promote a policy to increase the stock of housing in Guatemala, in an effort to enable more people from low-income sectors to rent or own their own homes;

(d) Increase the supply of housing-related services, housing options and high-quality, low-cost building materials; in this context, apply anti-trust regulations to the production and marketing of building materials and housing related services in accordance with article 130 of the Constitution;

Finance and credit

(e) Implement monetary policies designed to reduce the cost of credit significantly;

(f) Strengthen the securities market and make it more available as a source of funds to purchase housing, by offering first and second mortgages and facilitating the selling of securities issued for housing operations, such as common and preferred stocks in construction companies, mortgage bonds and debentures, real estate participation certificates, supplemental letters, promissory notes and other documents related to rental with an option to buy;

(g) Design a direct subsidy mechanism and apply it to the demand for low-cost housing, to benefit the most needy sectors. To this end, strengthen the Guatemalan Housing Fund to improve its capacity to grant funds to assist those living in poverty and extreme poverty;

Participation

(h) Stimulate the establishment and strengthening of participatory arrangements, such as cooperatives and self-managed and family businesses, to ensure that the beneficiaries are able to participate in the planning and construction of housing and related services;

Regularization of the land situation

(i) Promote the legalization, access to and registry of land, not only in the vicinity of Guatemala City but also for urban development in the province capitals and municipalities, together with the implementation of building projects in villages and on farms, especially rural housing;

National commitment

(j) In view of the size and urgency of the housing problem, national efforts should be mobilized to solve it. The Government undertakes to allocate to the housing promotion policy no less than 1.5 per cent of the tax revenue budget, beginning in 1997, giving priority to the subsidy for low-cost housing options.

E. Work

26. Work is essential for the integral development of the individual, the well-being of the family and the social and economic development of Guatemala. Labour relations are an essential element of social participation in socioeconomic development and of economic efficiency. In this respect, the State’s policy with regard to work is critical for a strategy of growth with social justice. In order to carry out this policy, the Government undertakes to:

Economic policy

(a) Through an economic policy designed to increase the use of the labor force, create conditions for the attainment of rising and sustained levels of employment, while sharply reducing structural underemployment and making possible a progressive increase in real wages;

(b) Encourage measures in coordination with the various social sectors to increase investment and productivity within the framework of an overall strategy of growth with social stability and equity;

Protective labor legislation

(c) Promote, in the course of 1996, legal and regulatory changes to enforce the labor laws and severely penalize violations, including violations in respect of the minimum wage, non-payment, withholding and delays in wages, occupational hygiene and safety and the work environment;

(d) Decentralize and expand labor inspection services, strengthening the capacity to monitor compliance with the labor norms of domestic law and those derived from the international labor agreements ratified by Guatemala, paying particular attention to monitoring compliance with the labor rights of women, migrant and temporary agricultural workers, household workers, minors, the elderly, the disabled and other workers who are in a more vulnerable and unprotected situation;

Occupational training

(e) Establish a permanent, modern vocational instruction and training program to ensure training at all levels and a corresponding increase in productivity through a draft law regulating vocational training at the national level;

(f) Promote coverage by the national vocational instruction and training programs of at least 200,000 workers by the year 2000, with an emphasis on those who are joining the workforce and those who need special training to adapt to new conditions in the labor market;

Ministry of Labor

(g) Strengthen and modernize the Ministry of Labour and Social Welfare, ensuring its leading role in Government policies related to the labor sector and its effective deployment in the promotion of employment and in labor cooperation. To that end, it undertakes to:

Participation, coordination and negotiations

(i) Promote the restructuring of labor relations in enterprises by encouraging labor management cooperation and coordination with a view to the development of the enterprise for the common good, including possible profit-sharing arrangements;

(ii) Facilitate the procedures for the recognition of the legal personality of labor organizations;

(iii) In the case of agricultural workers who are still hired through contractors, propose reforms for the speedy and flexible legal recognition of forms of association for the negotiation of such hiring; and

(iv) Promote a culture of negotiation and, in particular, train persons to settle disputes and coordinate action for the benefit of the parties involved.

III. Agrarian Situation and Rural Development

27. It is essential and unavoidable to solve the problems of agrarian reform and rural development in order to address the situation of the majority population, which live in rural areas and is most affected by poverty, extreme poverty, injustice and the weakness of State institutions. The transformation of the structure of land use and ownership must have as its objective the incorporation of the rural population into economic, social and political development so that the land constitutes, for those who work it, the basis of their economic stability, the foundation of their progressive social well-being and the guarantee of their freedom and dignity.

28. Land is central to the problems of rural development. From the conquest to the present, historic events, often tragic, have left deep traces in ethnic, social and economic relations concerning property and land use. These have led to a situation of concentration of resources which contrasts with the poverty of the majority and hinders the development of Guatemala as a whole. It is essential to redress and overcome this legacy and promote more efficient and more equitable farming, strengthening the potential of all those involved, not only in terms of productive capacity but also in enhancing the cultures and value systems which coexist and intermingle in the rural areas of Guatemala.

29. These changes will enable Guatemala to take full advantage of the capacities of its inhabitants and, in particular, the richness of the traditions and cultures of its indigenous peoples. It should also take advantage of the high potential for agricultural, industrial, commercial and tourist development of those resources deriving from its wealth of natural resources.

30. Solving the agrarian problem is a complex process covering many aspects of rural life, from modernization of production and cultivation methods to environmental protection, as well as security of property, adequate use of the land and of the labor force, labor protection and a more equitable distribution of resources and the benefits of development. This is also a social process whose success depends not only on the State, but also on a combination of efforts on the part of the organized sectors of society, in the awareness that the common good requires breaking with the patterns and prejudices of the past and seeking new and democratic forms of coexistence.

31. The State has a fundamental and vital role in this process. As the guide for national development, as a legislator, as a source of public investment and provider of services and as a promoter of social cooperation and conflict resolution, it is essential for the State to increase and refocus its efforts and its resources towards the rural areas, and to promote agrarian modernization, in a sustained manner, in the direction of greater justice and greater efficiency.

32. The agreements already signed on human rights, on the resettlement of populations uprooted by armed confrontation and on the identity and rights of indigenous peoples contain commitments which constitute essential elements of a global strategy for rural development. It is in line with these provisions that the Government undertakes, through this Agreement, to promote an integral strategy covering the multiple elements which make up agrarian structure, including land ownership and the use of natural resources; credit systems and mechanisms; manufacturing and marketing; agrarian legislation and legal security; labor relations; technical assistance and training; the sustainability of natural resources and the organization of the rural population. This strategy includes the aspects described below.

A. Participation

33. The capacity of all actors involved in the agricultural sector must be mobilized to make proposals and to take action, including indigenous peoples' organizations, producers' associations, business associations, rural workers' trade unions, rural and women's organizations or universities and research centers in Guatemala. To that end, in addition to the provisions of other chapters of this Agreement, the Government undertakes to:

(a) Strengthen the capacity of rural organizations such as associative rural enterprises, cooperatives, small farmers' associations, mixed enterprises and self-managed and family businesses to participate fully in decisions on all matters concerning them and to establish or strengthen State institutions, especially those of the State agricultural sector, involved in rural development so that they can promote such participation, particularly the full participation of women in the decision-making process. That will strengthen the effectiveness of State action and ensure that it responds to the needs of rural areas. In particular, participation in development councils will be promoted as a framework for the joint formulation of development and land use plans;

(b) Strengthen and expand the participation of tenant farmers' organizations, rural women, indigenous organizations, cooperatives, producers' trade unions and non-governmental organizations in the National Agricultural Development Council as the main mechanism for consultation, coordination and social participation in the decision-making process for rural development, and in particular for the implementation of this chapter.

B. Access to land and productive resources

34. Promote the access of tenant farmers to land ownership and the sustainable use of land resources. To that end, the Government will take the following actions:

Access to land ownership: land trust fund

(a) Establish a land trust fund within a broad-based banking institution to provide credit and to promote savings, preferably among micro-, small and medium-sized enterprises. The land trust fund will have prime responsibility for the acquisition of land through Government funding, will promote the establishment of a transparent land market and will facilitate the updating of land development plans. The fund will give priority to the allocation of land to rural men and women who are organized for that purpose, taking into account economic and environmental sustainability requirements;

(b) In order to ensure that the neediest sectors benefit from its services, the fund will set up a special advisory and management unit to serve rural communities and organizations;
(c) Initially, the fund will limit its activities to the following types of land:

(i) Uncultivated State land and State-owned farms;

(ii) Illegally settled public land, especially in Petan and the Franja Transversal del Norte, which the Government has pledged to recover through legal action;

(iii) Land acquired with the resources allocated by the Government to the National Land Fund and the National Peace Fund for that purpose;

(iv) Land purchased with grants from friendly Governments and international non-governmental organizations;

(v) Land purchased with loans secured from international financing agencies;

(vi) Undeveloped land expropriated under article 40 of the Constitution;

(vii) Land acquired from the proceeds of the sale of excess land, as determined by comparing the actual dimensions of private property with the dimensions recorded at the land register department, which has become the property of the State;

(viii) Land which the State may purchase pursuant to Decree No. 1551, article 40, on agricultural development areas;

(ix) Land which the State may purchase for any purpose; and

(x) Miscellaneous grants;

(d) The Government will promote and enact legislation to regulate all the activities of the land trust fund. Such legislation will establish, inter alia, the fund’s aims, functions and financing and acquisition mechanisms, and the allocation, origin and destination of land. In 1999, the extent to which the allocation targets have been met will be assessed and, if need be, the functioning of the land allocation program will be adjusted;

Access to land ownership: funding mechanisms

(e) Promote, through all means possible, the development of a dynamic land market that would enable tenant farmers who either do not have land or have insufficient land to acquire land through long-term transactions at commercial or favorable interest rates with little or no down payment. In particular, promote the issuance of mortgage-backed securities guaranteed by the State whose yield is attractive to private investors, especially financial institutions;

Access to other productive projects

(h) Develop sustainable productive projects especially geared towards boosting productivity and the processing of agricultural, forestry and fishery products in the poorest areas of the country. In particular, for the period 1997-2000, guarantee the implementation, in the poorest areas, of a Government agricultural sector investment program in the amount of 200 million quetzals in the agriculture, forestry and fisheries sectors;

(i) Promote a renewable natural resources management program which fosters sustainable forestry and agro-forestry production, as well as handicrafts and small- and medium-scale industry projects that give added value to forest products;

(j) Promote productive ventures related, inter alia, to agro-processing industries, marketing, services, handicrafts and tourism with a view to creating jobs and securing fair incomes for all;

(k) Promote an eco-tourism program with the broad participation of communities which have received appropriate training.

C. Support structure

35. Prerequisites for a more efficient and just agricultural structure include not only more equitable access to productive resources but also a support structure that will enhance farmers' access to information, technology, training, credit and marketing facilities. Over and above its commitment to social investment as set forth in the chapter on social development, including in particular investment in health, education, housing and employment, the Government also undertakes to:

Basic infrastructure

(a) Engage in judicious public investment and foster a climate conducive to private investment with a view to upgrading the infrastructure available for sustainable production and marketing, especially in areas of poverty and extreme poverty;

(b) Develop a rural development investment program with emphasis on basic infrastructure (highways, rural roads, electricity, telecommunications, water and environmental sanitation) and productive projects, for a total amount of 300 million quetzales annually during the period 1997-1999;

Credit and financial services

(c) Activate the land fund not later than 1997, while simultaneously promoting conditions that will enable small and medium-scale farmers to have access to credit, individually or in groups, on a financially sustainable basis. In particular, with the support of the private sector and non-governmental development organizations, the Government proposes to strengthen local savings and credit agencies, including associations, cooperatives and the like, with a view to enhancing their function as sources of credit providing small and medium-scale farmers with financial services efficiently and in accordance with local needs and conditions;

Training and technical assistance

(d) Strengthen, decentralize and broaden the coverage of training programs, especially programs designed to enhance rural people's managerial skills at various levels. The private sector and non-governmental organizations will be enlisted in the implementation of this action;

(e) Develop technical assistance and job training programs that will upgrade the skills, versatility and productivity of the labor force in rural areas;

Information

(f) Develop an information collection, compilation and distribution system for the agriculture, forestry, food processing and fisheries sectors, one that will provide small producers with reliable information on which to base their decisions relating to seeds, inputs, crops, costs and marketing;

Marketing

(g) Develop a system of storage centers and duty-free zones with a view to facilitating the processing and marketing of agricultural products and fostering rural employment.

D. Organization of the rural population for production

36. Organizing the rural population is a decisive factor in transforming the inhabitants of the countryside into genuine protagonists of their own development. In view of the vital role of small and medium-scale enterprises in combating poverty, creating rural jobs and promoting more efficient land use, there is a need to promote a more efficient form of organization of small producers so that they can, in particular, take advantage of the support structure described in paragraph 35. To this end, the Government undertakes to:

(a) Support micro-, small and medium-scale agricultural and rural enterprises by strengthening the various ways of organizing them, such as associative rural enterprises, cooperatives, small farmers' associations, mixed enterprises and self-managed and family businesses;

(b) Tackle the problem of smallholdings through:

(i) A firm and sustained policy of support for smallholders so that they can become small-scale agricultural businessmen through access to training, technology, credit and other inputs;

(ii) Promoting, if the smallholders so desire, amalgamation of holdings in those cases where conversion into small businesses is not possible owing to the dispersal and size of the properties.

E. Legal framework and juridical security

37. Guatemala is in need of reform of the juridical framework of agriculture and institutional development in the rural sector so that an end can be put to the lack of protection and dispossession from which small farmers, and in particular indigenous peoples, have suffered, so as to permit full integration of the rural population into the national economy and regulate land use in an efficient and environmentally sustainable manner in accordance with development needs. To this end, and taking into account in all cases the provisions of the Agreement on Identity and Rights of Indigenous Peoples, the Government undertakes to:

Legal reform

(a) Promote a legal reform which will establish a juridical framework governing land ownership that is secure, simple and accessible to the entire population. This reform will need to simplify the procedures for awarding title and registering ownership and other real estate rights, as well as to simplify administrative and judicial formalities and procedures;

(b) Promote the establishment of an agrarian and environmental jurisdiction within the judiciary through the enactment of the relevant legislation by the Congress;

(c) Promote the revision and adjustment of the legislation on undeveloped land so that it conforms to the provisions of the Constitution, and regulate, inter alia through incentives and penalties, the underutilization of land and its use in ways incompatible with sustainable natural resource utilization and preservation of the environment;

(d) Protect common and municipal land, in particular by limiting to the strict minimum the cases in which it can be transferred or handed over in whatever form to private individuals;

(e) With respect to community-owned land, to regulate participation by communities in order to ensure that it is they who take the decisions relating to their land;

Prompt settlement of land conflicts

(f) To establish and apply flexible judicial or non-judicial procedures for the settlement of disputes relating to land and other natural resources (in particular, direct settlement and conciliation), taking into account the provisions of the Agreement on Resettlement of the Population Groups Uprooted by the Armed Conflict and the Agreement on Identity and Rights of Indigenous People. In addition, to establish procedures that will make it possible:

(i) To define formulas for compensation in the case of land disputes and claims in which farmers, small farmers and communities in a situation of extreme poverty have been or may be dispossessed for reasons not attributable to them;

(ii) To reinstate or compensate, as appropriate, the State, municipalities, communities or individuals when their land has been usurped or has been allocated in an irregular or unjustified manner involving abuse of authority;

(g) Regulate the award of title to the lands of indigenous communities and beneficiaries of the Guatemalan Institute for Agrarian Reform who are in lawful possession of the land assigned to them;

Institutional mechanisms

(h) By 1997, to have started the operations of a Presidential office for legal assistance and conflict resolution in relation to land, with nationwide coverage and the task of providing advice and legal assistance to small farmers and agricultural workers with a view to the full exercise of their rights, and in particular of:

(i) Advising and providing legal assistance to small farmers and agricultural workers and/or their organizations upon request;

(ii) Intervening in land disputes at the request of a party with a view to arriving at a just and expeditious solution;

(iii) In the case of judicial disputes, providing advice and legal assistance free of charge to small farmers and/or their organizations when they so request;

(iv) Receiving complaints of abuses committed against communities, rural organizations and individual small farmers and bringing them to the attention of the Office of the Counsel for Human Rights and/or of any other national or international verification mechanism.

G. Land register

38. On the basis of the provisions of paragraph 37, the Government undertakes to promote legislative changes that would make it possible to establish an efficient decentralized multi-user land registry system that is financially sustainable, subject to compulsory updating and easy to update. Likewise, the Government undertakes to initiate, by January 1997 at the latest, the process of land surveying and systematizing the land register information, starting with priority zones, in particular with a view to the implementation of paragraph 34 on access to land and other production resources.

H. Labor protection

39. The Government undertakes to promote better participation of rural workers in the benefits of agriculture and a reorientation of labor relations in rural areas. It will place particular emphasis on applying to rural workers the labor policy outlined in the relevant section of the present agreement. An energetic labor protection policy, combined with a vocational training policy, is in line with the requirements of social justice. It is also needed in order to attack rural poverty and promote an agrarian reform aimed at more efficient use of natural and human resources. Accordingly, the Government undertakes to:

(a) Ensure that the labour legislation is effectively applied in rural areas;

(b) Pay urgent attention to the abuses to which rural migrant workers, young tenant farmers and day laborers are subjected in the context of hiring through middlemen, sharecropping, payment in kind and the use of weights and measures. The Government undertakes to adopt administrative and/or penal sanctions against offenders;

(c) Promote reform of the procedures for recognition of the legal personality of small farmers' organizations with a view to simplifying such recognition and making it more flexible through the application of the 1975 International Labour Organization Convention 141 on organization of rural workers.

I. Environmental protection

40. Guatemala's natural wealth is a valuable asset of the country and mankind, in addition to being an essential part of the cultural and spiritual heritage of the indigenous peoples. The irrational exploitation of Guatemala's biogenetic and forest resource diversity endangers a human environment that facilitates sustainable development. Sustainable development is understood as being a process of change in the life of the human being through economic growth with social equity, involving production methods and consumption patterns that maintain the ecological balance. This process implies respecting ethnic and cultural diversity and guaranteeing the quality of life of future generations.

41. In this sense, and in line with the principles of the Central American Alliance for Sustainable Development, the Government reiterates the following commitments:

(a) To adjust educational curricula and training and technical assistance programs to the requirements of environmental sustainability;

(b) To give priority to environmental sanitation in its health policy;

(c) To link physical planning policies, particularly urban planning, with environmental protection;

(d) To promote sustainable natural resource management programs that will create jobs.

J. Resources

42. In order to finance the measures mentioned above, and in view of the priority assigned to modernizing the agriculture sector and rural development, the Government undertakes to increase the State resources allocated to this area by, inter alia:

Land tax

(a) Promoting, by 1997, the legislation and mechanisms for the application, in consultation with municipalities, of a land tax in the rural areas from which it is easy for the municipalities to collect revenues. The tax, from which small properties will be exempt, will help to discourage ownership of undeveloped land and underutilization of land. Taken as a whole, these mechanisms ought not to encourage deforestation of land use for forestry;

Tax on undeveloped land

(b) Establishing a new tax schedule for the annual tax on undeveloped land which imposes significantly higher taxes on privately owned unutilized and/or underutilized land.

IV. Modernization of Government Services and Fiscal Policy

A. Modernization of government services

43. Government services should become an efficient tool of development policies. To this end, the Government undertakes to:

Decentralization and redistribution

(a) Deepen the decentralization and redistribution of the powers, responsibilities and resources concentrated in the central Government in order to modernize, render effective and streamline government services. Decentralization should ensure the transfer of decision-making power and sufficient resources to the appropriate levels (local, municipal, departmental and regional) so as to meet the needs of socio-economic development in an efficient way and promote close cooperation between government bodies and the population. This implies:

(i) Promoting an amendment to the Executive Authority Act and the Departmental Control and Administration Act and, in particular, to Decree No. 586 of 1956, which will make it possible to simplify, decentralize and redistribute government services;

(ii) Promoting the decentralization of support systems, including the purchasing and procurement system, the human resources system, the information-gathering and statistical system and the financial management system.

National auditing

(b) Reform, strengthen and modernize the Comptroller’s Office. Professionalization and advancement of public servants

44. The State should have a skilled labor force which can ensure the honest and efficient management of public funds. To this end, it is necessary to:

(a) Establish a career civil service;

(b) Adopt legal and administrative measures to ensure real compliance with the Integrity and Accountability Act;

(c) Promote criminal sanctions for acts of corruption and misappropriation of public funds.

B. Fiscal policy

45. Fiscal policy (revenue and expenditure) is the key tool enabling the State to comply with its constitutional commitments, particularly those relating to social development, which is essential to the quest for the common good. Fiscal policy is also essential to Guatemalan sustainable development, which has been impaired by low levels of education, health care and public security, a lack of infrastructure and other factors which militate against increasing the productivity of labor and the competitiveness of the Guatemalan economy.

Budgetary policy

46. Budgetary policy should respond to the need for socio-economic development in a stable context, which requires a public spending policy consistent with the following basic principles:

(a) Giving priority to social spending, the provision of public services and the basic infrastructure needed to support production and marketing;

(b) Giving priority to social investment in health care, education and housing; rural development; job creation; and compliance with the commitments entered into under the peace agreements. The budget should include sufficient resources for strengthening the organizations and institutions responsible for ensuring the rule of law and respect for human rights;

(c) Efficient budget performance, with an emphasis on decentralization, redistribution and auditing of budgetary resources.

Tax policy

47. Tax policy should be designed to enable the collection of the resources needed for the performance of the State’s functions, including the funds required for the consolidation of peace, within the framework of a tax system consistent with the following basic principles:

(a) The system is fair, equitable and, on the whole, progressive, in keeping with the constitutional principle of ability to pay;

(b) The system is universal and compulsory;

(c) The system stimulates saving and investment.

48. The State should also ensure efficiency and transparency in tax collection and fiscal management so as to promote taxpayer confidence in government policy and eliminate tax evasion and fraud.

Tax collection target

49. Bearing in mind the need to increase State revenues in order to cope with the urgent tasks of economic growth, social development and building peace, the Government undertakes to ensure that by the year 2000, the tax burden, measured as a ratio of gross domestic product, increases by at least 50 per cent as compared with the 1995 tax burden.

Fiscal commitment

50. As a step towards a fair and equitable tax system, the Government undertakes to address the most serious issue relating to tax injustice and inequity, namely, evasion and fraud, especially on the part of those who should be the largest contributors. In order to eradicate privileges and abuses, eliminate tax evasion and fraud and implement a tax system which is, on the whole, progressive, the Government undertakes to:

Legislation

(a) Promote an amendment to the Tax Code establishing harsher penalties for tax evasion, avoidance and fraud, both for taxpayers and for tax administration officials;

(b) Promote an amendment to the tax laws designed to eliminate loopholes;

(c) Evaluate and regulate tax exemptions strictly so as to eliminate abuses;

Strengthening of tax administration

(d) Strengthen the existing auditing and collection mechanisms, such as cross-checking, tax identification numbers and tax credits for withholding of income tax and value-added tax;

(e) Simplify and automate tax administration procedures;

(f) Ensure the correct and prompt application or reimbursement of tax credit and punish severely those who do not return withheld value-added tax to the tax authorities;

(g) Create a special program for large contributors in order to ensure that they comply fully with their tax obligations;

(h) Implement administrative structures specifically geared to the revenue collection and auditing programs and to the application of the relevant tax laws;

(i) Strengthen the capacity of municipalities to exercise their authority to collect taxes;

Participation

(j) Ensure that the urban and rural development councils contribute to the definition and monitoring of tax policy within the framework of their mandate to formulate development policies;

Civic education

(k) Within academic curricula, continue to promote knowledge of,
respect for and compliance with tax obligations as part of coexistence in a democratic society.

Enforcement of tax policy

51. The failure to fulfill tax obligations deprives the country of the resources needed in order to address the backlog of social needs affecting Guatemalan society. The Government undertakes to impose exemplary penalties on those who engage in various types of tax fraud, to modernize and strengthen tax administration and to give priority to spending on social needs.

V. Final Provisions

1. This Agreement shall form part of the agreement on a firm and lasting peace and shall enter into force at the time of the signing of the latter agreement.

2. In order to ensure that this Agreement serves the interests of Guatemalans, the Government shall initiate immediately the programming and planning activities which will enable it to comply with the investment commitments contained herein.

3. In accordance with the Framework Agreement, the Secretary-General of the United Nations is requested to verify compliance with this Agreement.

4. This Agreement shall be disseminated as widely as possible; to this end, the cooperation of the mass media and of teaching and educational institutions is requested.

Implementation History

1997

Intermediate Implementation

The Ministry of Finance submitted a report on fiscal policy commitments on 10 April 1997. Included in the report were plans for a number of tax reforms designed to meet the stipulations in the Agreement on Social and Economic Aspects and the Agrarian Situation, especially to increase tax revenue to 12% of gross domestic product by the year 2000. On 16 April, the Government submitted plans for over 120 million US dollars in public investment for rural development, which surpassed the amount required by the Agreements.1

The Follow-up Commission accepted the Government's request to delay the process of amending the Urban and Rural Development Council Act. A lack of funding and coordination problems led to delays in initiating the national municipal training program. At 9% of GDP, the tax burden fulfilled and surpassed the level set by the Agreements for 1997 (8.6%), but the rate of public spending was much lower than projected. Some efforts were made to improve tax administration and enforcement, which was to be the main catalyst for increases in tax revenue stipulated in the Agreements. The Government also made strides toward the agricultural and rural development reforms specified by the Agreements, especially with resource allocations and land dispute resolution mechanisms. It also introduced legislation to establish the Land Trust Fund, and Congress approved the bill to change the name of the National Agricultural Development Bank (BANDESA) to the Rural Development Bank (BANRURAL) and restructure it according to the Agreements.2

Some institutional reforms were made in the health care sector, but officials did not fully internalize the reforms, spending fell short of budgeted amounts, and there was little evidence of improvement in public health in 1997.3

The Government gathered resources for the Guatemalan Housing Fund from tax revenues and a loan from the Inter-American Development Bank, which it planned to begin distributing in 1998. The Ministry of Labor and Social Welfare completed draft amendments to the Labor Code, but it did not include all the collective bargaining rights for agricultural workers stipulated by the Agreements.4

  • 1. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/51/936), June 30, 1997.
  • 2. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/52/757), February 4, 1998.
  • 3. Ibid.
  • 4. Ibid.
1998

Intermediate Implementation

Favorable macroeconomic performance in Guatemala facilitated the government's compliance with the Agreement on Social and Economic Aspects and the Agrarian Situation in 1998. Spending on basic social services increased and the economic and social infrastructure was generally improved, both of which contributed to increases in public investment and job creation. There was a deadlock between planning agencies over the municipal training program, but it was resolved, and municipal development councils built up their capacities. The Ministry of Agriculture began the process of policy reform and transitioning state institutions for agricultural and rural development. The Guatemalan Housing Fund (FOGUAVI) failed to meet its commitment to award at least half of its subsidies to the rural population, and spending on housing was generally below budget. FOGUAVI was also unnecessarily slow in responding to the issue of urban squatter settlements. The Ministry of Health worked on implementing the Integrated Health Care System (SIAS), but geographic coverage had a long way to go and inadequate vaccination coverage failed to contain outbreaks of preventable diseases. The Program of Access to Medicines (PROAM) was operating in compliance with the Agreements. Tax revenue grew, but not enough to meet the target of 10.4% of GDP for the year due to reductions in property taxes and tariffs. The Ministry of Finance revised projections for raising tax revenue to the stipulated 12% of GDP and convinced the Follow-up Commission to allow the target date to be pushed back from 2000 to 2002.5

The Ministry of Labor and Social Security adopted official policies in keeping with the Agreements, and the Labor Code was amended according to the draft submitted in 1997. While additional improvements were made in labor dispute settlement process, workers' rights to unionize were still impeded, the Ministry of Labor was still overly centralized, legislation had yet to be introduced for vocational and technical training programs, and resources were lacking to properly initiate the School for Labor Mediation and Conciliation.6

In mid-1998 the Follow-up Commission gave priority to fiscal and rural problems. Hurricane Mitch ravaged much of Central America in October 1998, shifting the focus of many of the development efforts to disaster relief and reconstruction.7

  • 5. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/53/421), September 28, 1998.
  • 6. Ibid.
  • 7. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/54/526), November 11, 1999.
1999

Intermediate Implementation

The Government undertook to respond appropriately to the damage from Hurricane Mitch without compromising its commitments to the implementation of the Peace Agreements. It succeeded in fulfilling its disaster response plans, but those efforts did in fact hinder progress in the economic and social development components of the Agreements.8

The Fiscal Pact Preparatory Commission was established in March 1998 to help reach the goal of raising tax revenue to 12% of GDP by 2002. The Congress approved the Land Trust Fund Act, and the Ministry of Agriculture, Livestock and Food set priorities and strategies for economic and social development in keeping with the Agreements. Real improvements were made in the equitable distribution of public investment between rural and urban areas. The Presidential Unit for Legal Assistance and Dispute Settlement in Land Matters (CONTIERRA) helped reduce conflicts over agricultural lands, but little progress was made in land registration and legislation had yet to be passed to clarify who has jurisdiction over undeveloped land.9

Public spending on health increased, both in absolute terms and in proportion to total public spending, which in turn improved the health infrastructure and health services coverage. The Ministry of Health and SIAS improved the cost-efficiency of their services and reached out to sectors of the population previously left without access to health care. However, health services still wanted for quality and public health indicators showed the rate of progress was not enough to meet all of the standards set by the Agreements. Infant mortality, for example, was supposed to be brought down to about 25 deaths per 1000 live births by the year 2000, but at the beginning of 1999 it was only down to 45 in 1000. Vaccination coverage was also still insufficient to prevent epidemics.10

Budget allocations for housing development reached the benchmark of 1.5% of annual tax revenue, thus fulfilling the commitment made in the Agreements. However, the services provided by FOGUAVI and FONAPAZ most directly benefited private industry and lacked quality control measures. Housing policies were also more generally failing to meet the purpose, as stipulated by the Agreements, of enabling poor people to have access to affordable housing in safe and sustainable condition.11

The Government did not make good progress with regard to labor laws, union protections and equitable vocational training. Labor union organizers faced harassment, threats and direct violence, even murder. The alleged perpetrators were either unknown or claimed to represent local citizens.12

2000

Intermediate Implementation

Following the rescheduling of the taxation target from 2000 to 2002, the Follow-up Commission spearheaded a consultative process involving many sectors of society, which culminated in the signing of the Fiscal Pact for a Future with Peace and Development. The Pact clarified the long-term plans the Government would need to follow in order to enact a fiscal policy in keeping with the Peace Agreements. A similar consultative process led by the Follow-up Commission established the Political Agreement for Funding Peace, Development and Democracy in Guatemala. This agreement added specific measures for tax reform and paved the way for further reform policies negotiated between the executive and legislative branches.13

The Government continued to falter in its implementation of policies related to rural development. No comprehensive rural development strategy was yet proposed, definitions of agrarian and environmental jurisdictions had not been set, the land registry issue was unresolved, and the land rights of indigenous communities were not codified. The Government did make some steps in the right direction with its environmental policies, but the agricultural policy it set for 2000-2004 lacked guarantees for multiculturalism, procedures to ensure indigenous peoples would be involved in decisions about their own development, and affirmative action programs for women and rural youth. By the end of 2000, BANRURAL increased its loan portfolio with a focus on areas most affected by the conflict.14

The Government did not invest nearly as much time and energy as was needed to address the country's labor problems. The main improvement was the increase in the minimum wage. The main corresponding problem was the Ministry of Labor had neither the financial resources nor the institutional capacity to ensure that historically exploited workers—indigenous persons, women, children and rural agricultural workers in general—would be treated fairly and paid their due wages.15

The new governmental authorities were quite slow in reviewing all the social development programs and hindered progress in so doing. The approved budget for public investment was cut by 20% and spending even fell short of budgeted amounts, which especially affected spending in the country's poorest areas. The spending reductions did not adversely affect public health programs. The new National Health Plan 2000-2004 set budgeted spending levels consistent with the Agreements, included measures to decentralize and improve coordination, and prioritized extending access to health care to groups previously unreached by the services, especially indigenous women and migrant workers.16

While adequate amounts were budgeted for housing development programs, FOGUAVI was deactivated and spending ceased, leading to a spike in unemployment among construction workers and growing discontent among the would-be beneficiaries of new housing.17

The network of local development councils was not living up to its intended purpose of engendering broad social participation in municipal and community projects. Despite reform measures enacted by the Executive Branch designed to foster local participation in the selection of leaders, gubernatorial candidates put forward by non-governmental members of development councils were largely sidelined.18

  • 13. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/55/175), July 26, 2000.
  • 14. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/55/175), July 26, 2000; “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/55/973), June 1, 2001.
  • 15. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/55/175), July 26, 2000.
  • 16. Ibid.
  • 17. Ibid.
  • 18. Ibid.
2001

Intermediate Implementation

The implementation of the peace agreements lagged in 2001 in general.19

The budget of the SIAS shrunk by 23% compared to the previous year, when it should have grown in order to stay on target for the expansion stipulated by the Agreements. Health care coverage was not yet extended to include migrant workers. The National Health Council was established in March 2001 to improve coordination in the provision of health services. In keeping with the Healthy Schools Plan, meal programs were initiated in 16,000 schools, but no action had yet been taken to combat malnutrition among children under the age of five. Likewise, vaccination coverage in children was still insufficient, and the water supply was unreliable in rural areas. The Ministry of Health and Social Welfare launched a program to provide reproductive health services across the country.20

A discussion set up by the Vice-Ministry led to an agreement between the Government and civil society leaders on a national housing and human settlements policy, which was approved in August 2001. It set clear priorities on resolving the housing shortage, especially among the country's poorest people. The Government pledged to reactivate FOGUAVI, but it did not yet create a budget to do so.21

The drop in international prices for some of Guatemala's main exports—most notably coffee—had a dramatic negative impact on local economic enterprise, especially for small and medium-sized farms, which were already struggling to compete against the large agricultural conglomerates in Guatemala. Income inequality continued on unmitigated, as the Ministry of Labor was still unable to enforce minimum wage laws. On the positive side, it did become easier to register trade unions and some consultation meetings produced draft legislation to bring the country's Labor Code into compliance with International Labor Organization standards.22

No significant progress was made toward comprehensive rural development. The rural populations continued to suffer from poverty and inequitable access to state resources. Reforms to improve land registry and clarify agrarian and environmental jurisdiction were further delayed. Displaced persons especially suffered from social exclusion and denied access to land. Whatever projects were implemented were piecemeal and short-sighted.23 The Land Trust Fund did not receive all of its budgeted funds.24

  • 19. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/55/1003), July 10, 2002.
  • 20. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/55/973), June 1, 2001.
  • 21. Ibid; “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/55/1003), July 10, 2002.
  • 22. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/55/973), June 1, 2001.
  • 23. Ibid.
  • 24. Ibid; “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/55/1003), July 10, 2002.
2002

Intermediate Implementation

A new program began to prevent childhood diseases. Vaccination coverage against measles and polio increased, and the latter was effectively eradicated.25

The budget approved for the Land Trust Fund was much lower than it requested, even though there was a high demand for credit. The shortage of loan resources caused tensions and confrontations. In April 2002, members of the National Council for Displaced Guatemalans occupied several offices of the Land Trust Fund to demand access to land and loans. The Follow-up Commission intervened and the Government made moves to increase the Land Trust Fund's budget.26

The issue of agrarian and environmental jurisdiction was finally addressed with the passage of an agrarian reform bill in Congress, but it was not yet implemented and some ambiguity about idle land remained. A Secretariat of Agrarian Affairs was also established. A land registry bill, endorsed by the Follow-up Commission, was also submitted and debated in Congress, but President Portillo withdrew it for revision. The lack of a coherent land registry system was a major hindrance to progress in rural development.27

The BANRURAL raised the credit and financial services offered substantially, but most of the poor in the rural areas could not get loans because they lacked titles to land.28

The recent moves to eliminate and prevent child labor were not enforced.29 The Social Security Institute did not as yet extend services to indigenous people.30

The Government failed to increase tax revenues to 12% of GDP, even though the deadline was extended from 2000 to 2002. The actual rate for 2002 was 10.6% of GDP. While the Government is held responsible for this failure to implement a component of the Peace Agreements, the private sector is also partly to blame for organizing resistance to tax increases.31

Congress passed the Urban and Rural Development Council Act with Legislative Decree No. 11-2002, and the General Decentralization Act with Decree No. 12-2002.32

  • 25. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/55/1003), July 10, 2002.
  • 26. Ibid.
  • 27. Ibid; “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/58/267), August 11, 2003.
  • 28. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/55/1003), July 10, 2002.
  • 29. Ibid.
  • 30. Ibid.
  • 31. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/58/267), August 11, 2003.
  • 32. “Information Received from Governments: Guatemala,” Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues, United Nations Economic and Social Council, (E/C.19/2010/12/Add.8), March 3, 2010.
2003

Intermediate Implementation

A continuing decline in the price of coffee in the global market exacerbated the difficulty the agricultural sector in Guatemala was already experiencing since 2001. The Government agreed to fund a “coffee emergency” plan, which was designed to assist rural peasants by encouraging crop diversification and helping unemployed Guatemalans in rural areas acquire land.33

Overall, the 2003 budget improved over the previous year's budget, but there were some significant shortfalls. The Presidential Office for Legal Assistance and Dispute Settlement in Land Matters was defunded in the 2003 budget. The Government provided some temporary provisions, but the office staff and coverage area were severely cut. Budget allocations for the Land Trust Fund similarly fell below the amount set by the Agreements. The Ministry of Health also suffered cutbacks, resulting in reductions in basic preventive services, especially in rural and indigenous areas.34

Some core issues from the armed conflict were left unresolved due to the Government's incomplete implementation of the Peace Agreements. In particular, public services were deficient, rural development efforts did not significantly increase opportunities for rural communities, and many land conflicts were never resolved. Indicators of economic development showed no improvement in income disparity through the peace process, and an actual increase in extreme poverty toward the end of the implementation phase. Much of the failure to improve economic and social development resulted from lower than expected tax revenues and subsequent spending cuts.35

  • 33. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/58/267), August 11, 2003.
  • 34. Ibid.
  • 35. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/59/307), August 30, 2004.
2004

Intermediate Implementation

There was a sharp rise in violent land evictions, exacerbating humanitarian problems for rural communities.36

In June, the Mayan Farmers' Front organized a 48-hour strike to protest the forced eviction of landless rural workers from idle lands. As a result, President Berger announced a suspension of evictions and other concessions.37

The commitments regarding increasing tax revenue, expanding and improving public services, promoting development in rural areas especially, rejuvenating the public health system, and resolving land disputes were not fulfilled by the rescheduled deadline of 31 December 2004.

  • 36. “United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala: Report of the Secretary-General,” United Nations General Assembly (A/59/746), March 18, 2005.
  • 37. “Guatemala,” Keesing's Record of World Events (Volume 50), June 2004, 46052.
2005

Intermediate Implementation

No developments observed this year.

2006

Intermediate Implementation

After years of attempted economic development, 57% of the population still lived in poverty, with 21% in extremely poor conditions. Guatemala had one of the worst rates of wealth inequality in the world.38 In 2006, President Berger embarked on a campaign to evict squatters from farmland they seized during the previous administration. One group of peasant farmers rose up and attempted to re-capture an estate by force after the owners fired hundreds of workers. At least five people were killed in the clash.39

  • 38. “Report of the High Commissioner for Human Rights on the Situation of Human Rights in Guatemala,” United Nations Economic and Social Council (E/CN.4/2006/10/Add.1), February 1, 2006.
  • 39. “Five Killed in Guatemala Clash over Land,” The Gazette (Montreal), July 10, 2006, A16.